Should You Get Rental Car Insurance? A Complete Guide

Renting a car for a trip or when your vehicle is in the shop can be incredibly convenient. However, it also comes with a question that many drivers face: should you purchase rental car insurance? With various types of coverage available and so many factors to consider, making the right choice can be tricky. Understanding the ins and outs of rental car insurance is important for ensuring that you’re not overpaying for coverage you don’t need—or worse, left unprotected in case of an accident.

This guide will help you understand rental car insurance, what it covers, and whether it’s something you should add to your rental agreement.

What Is Rental Car Insurance?

Rental car insurance is a policy that provides coverage for rental vehicles. It’s designed to protect you from financial responsibility in case of an accident, theft, or damage during the rental period. When you rent a car, you are typically given the option to purchase insurance directly from the rental car company. These insurance options can be relatively expensive, but they can offer peace of mind if you’re unfamiliar with the car or concerned about potential risks.

Rental car insurance generally falls into several categories, including:

Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Liability Coverage
Personal Accident Insurance (PAI)
Personal Effects Coverage (PEC)

Do You Really Need Rental Car Insurance?

Whether or not you need rental car insurance depends on several factors, including your existing auto insurance policy, your credit card benefits, and your personal risk tolerance. Here’s a breakdown of the most common situations and how they affect your need for rental car insurance:

1. Your Existing Auto Insurance

The first place to check before renting a car is your personal auto insurance policy. If you have comprehensive and collision coverage on your car, it likely extends to rental cars as well. That means your regular car insurance may cover any damage or theft that occurs while you’re renting a vehicle.

Before you decline the rental car company’s insurance, review your policy to ensure that:

You have collision and comprehensive coverage.
Your policy applies to rental vehicles.
You understand any exclusions or limits regarding rental car coverage, such as restrictions on international rentals.

If your auto insurance policy covers rental cars, you might not need the rental company’s Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW). However, keep in mind that you may still be liable for a deductible, and your rental car insurance may not cover things like theft or personal injuries.

2. Credit Card Benefits

Many major credit cards, particularly those offering travel benefits, include rental car insurance as part of their travel protections. Typically, these benefits only apply if you pay for the rental car with your credit card. The coverage can vary based on the card, but it generally includes collision damage and may offer coverage for theft or vandalism as well.

Before you rely on credit card coverage, you should:

Check with your credit card provider to confirm the details of their rental car insurance policy.
Ensure that the card you plan to use offers secondary coverage (or primary coverage, if applicable).
Decline the rental car company’s CDW if you plan to use your credit card’s coverage (since you usually can’t use both).

Credit card rental car insurance generally does not cover liability or medical expenses, which means you may still need to purchase additional insurance for protection against those costs.

3. International Travel

If you’re traveling outside of your home country, your personal auto insurance and credit card coverage may not apply. International rental car insurance can be tricky, as policies vary widely by country. In some places, rental agencies may offer their own mandatory insurance, while others may require you to purchase a local policy.

Before renting a car internationally:

Review your auto insurance and credit card policy to determine whether they provide coverage abroad.
Check the rental agency’s requirements for insurance in the country where you’re renting.

4. Your Risk Tolerance

Even if your personal auto insurance or credit card offers some coverage, you may still opt to purchase rental car insurance if you want additional peace of mind. Rental cars are often driven in unfamiliar areas, and accidents can happen, particularly when you’re not used to the vehicle. If you’re concerned about the possibility of an accident or don’t want to risk dealing with a complex claims process, rental car insurance may be worth considering.

Some people also purchase rental insurance to avoid the potential deductible on their own auto insurance policy, or to avoid any increased premiums resulting from claims.

Types of Rental Car Insurance

Rental car companies offer various types of insurance. Here’s an overview of the most common types:

1. Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) / Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)

This is the most common form of rental car insurance. It covers damage to the rental car in the event of an accident, theft, or vandalism. In some cases, it may even cover incidents like weather damage (like hail), but coverage can vary by company.

CDW/LDW Coverage: It’s not technically “insurance” but a waiver of responsibility. If you decline the waiver, you may be responsible for the full cost of repairs or the car’s market value if the vehicle is totaled.
What It Covers: Accidental damage to the car, theft, and vandalism.
What It Doesn’t Cover: Personal injury, damage to other vehicles, or injury to other people.

2. Liability Insurance

Liability coverage protects you in the event that you cause an accident and are responsible for injuries or damage to other people or property. Many countries, especially in Europe, require you to have third-party liability insurance when renting a car.

What It Covers: Damage or injury caused to others, including passengers, other drivers, and pedestrians.
What It Doesn’t Cover: Damage to your rental car.

3. Personal Accident Insurance (PAI)

This type of insurance provides coverage for medical expenses that might arise if you or your passengers are injured during the rental period. It’s especially useful if you don’t have personal health insurance or if you’re traveling abroad.

What It Covers: Medical costs for you and your passengers in the event of an accident.
What It Doesn’t Cover: Damage to the car or property damage.

4. Personal Effects Coverage (PEC)

This insurance covers the loss of personal items from the rental car. It can be useful if you have valuables, such as electronics, in the vehicle during your trip.

What It Covers: Theft of personal belongings from the rental car.
What It Doesn’t Cover: Loss of items from your hotel room, home, or other locations.

What’s the Bottom Line?

In most cases, if you have existing auto insurance or coverage through your credit card, you may not need to purchase additional rental car insurance. However, be sure to check with both your insurance company and credit card provider to understand what’s covered and any exclusions.

For international travel or those with no existing coverage, purchasing rental car insurance might be a wise choice, particularly for collision damage, liability, and theft protection.

Ultimately, the decision to purchase rental car insurance depends on your personal situation, the type of trip you’re taking, and your level of comfort with potential risks. Always review your coverage options, and if in doubt, speak with your rental agency to clarify their insurance offerings.

Read More: